Bath’s £2.35 million cycle route has an Indiana Jones problem

In The Big Bang Theory, Amy Farrah Fowler spoils Raiders of the Lost Ark for Sheldon by pointing out that, if Indiana Jones had stayed at home, the film would have ended much the same way. Try the same test on Bath’s “family-friendly” cycle lane. Imagine a parent deciding whether their daughter can cycle home from the city centre to Weston on a late winter afternoon. Now imagine the £2.35 million works in Royal Victoria Park are finished. What changes that parent’s answer?

Follow her journey home in the dark. She has to negotiate Queen Square before she reaches the park. At the far end, she has to ride through the Weston Road and Park Lane roundabout. The preliminary route assessment, disclosed under information request FOIEIR1041, records that cyclists mix with motor traffic there without protection. It identifies a critical issue. Against the question “Resolved by Design”, the answer is “No”. As for Queen Square, the council’s October update said it was still developing designs and seeking funding. Yet B&NES announced the park works as making the journey from Weston into the city centre “safer and quicker”.

What did the council know about safety?

In September, Councillor Saskia Heijltjes asked council leader Kevin Guy what B&NES was doing to ensure the safety of women and children using the proposed route. Guy said the improvements would provide “safe, healthy, and fair access to the park”. He expected two-way use to improve natural surveillance. In plain English, he expected other people to be around to see someone who needed help. What evidence did he have about who would be there on a dark Tuesday afternoon?

On 22 September, Chris Major, B&NES’s Director for Place Management, signed the traffic order decision. The report described the route as family-friendly. It recorded one response under the heading “The lane will be dark at night”. Officers answered in one sentence about lighting standards. Major concluded that the arguments for and against the scheme had been “considered fully”. Original decision report, pages 5, 13 and 15

Walk Ride Bath had submitted a formal objection asking who overlooked the route, what a rider could see ahead and how she could leave if she felt threatened. On 22 October, B&NES acknowledged that our objection had never reached the decision-maker. By then the order had been sealed. The council revoked its decision and took it again. The council’s information response

The second time around, the answer ran to several pages. Major acknowledged that lighting would leave some personal-security concerns unresolved and that parts of the route would still have limited natural surveillance. Officers confirmed that they had left three Active Travel England indicators unscored. What those codes mean matters to anyone who has ever made their way home alone after dark. Revised decision report, pages 14–19

  • SP04. Who can see me? Do homes or other buildings overlook this stretch? Are people likely to be passing at the time I use it? If I needed help, who would notice?
  • SP05. Can I see ahead, and can I get away? Do trees, walls or bends hide what is coming? If something ahead makes me uneasy, is there another way out, or do I have to carry on towards it?
  • SP06. Can I see who else is here? Can I make out someone standing beside the route after dark? Does the lighting leave deep shadows or places where someone could remain hidden until I am close?

A lamp can help a girl see the path ahead. It cannot put another person within sight or give her another way out. And it was SP04, the question of who would actually be there, that went directly to Guy’s assurance in September.

Officers said the three indicators were placemaking indicators and therefore did not require scoring. Paragraph 2.10 of Active Travel England’s manual identifies both the Street Check and the Street Placemaking Check as mandatory for street-based schemes. Paragraph 9.3 tells assessors to score the existing layout and the proposed design against each metric and record their assumptions. If different instructions applied here, B&NES should publish them. I have referred the final report to the council’s Monitoring Officer and asked for corrections.

Whose journey gets shorter?

People could already cycle through the park on its clockwise road. For a rider entering from Weston Road and heading towards the city centre, we measured about 0.7 miles to Royal Avenue around that road and about 0.5 miles using the new contraflow. A cycle journey planner also shows an existing route via Weston Road and the diagonal park path at the same rounded distance of 0.5 miles. Officers give a reason for preferring the new lane: the diagonal path is narrow, is shared with pedestrians and has a surface they consider unsuitable for cycling in wet weather. Those are reasons to examine safety and usability. The distance saving depends on which route a cyclist would otherwise have taken. Revised decision report, section 9

What happened to the request from the park gate?

Asked about the scheme in November, Cllr Manda Rigby spoke about investing in a much-loved park, protecting its heritage and making it more accessible. She also said the plans would reduce tension between people walking and cycling on shared paths. Better pavements and crossings are worthwhile in their own right. Her explanation invites a very local question. What happens at the entrance opposite Tennyson Road, where people on foot and on bikes already meet?

Someone asked about that entrance during the original consultation. Appendix D records a request to upgrade it because it would give people access to quieter roads as an alternative to Upper Bristol Road. People already cycle this way to avoid Windsor Bridge junction. The new zebra helps pedestrians cross Park Lane. The contraflow gives cyclists a lawful route along the park road. The published scheme still shows no designated cycle link through the gate between the two. Someone arriving by bike must dismount to use the footway or ride through the space pedestrians are using.

B&NES itself cited the risk of pedestrians and cyclists sharing the narrow diagonal path. Did officers visit the Tennyson Road entrance with the people who use it? What options did they consider for resolving the same conflict there? The council can point to the page where it recorded the suggestion. Residents should be able to turn to the page where it gave them an answer.

Why didn’t B&NES upgrade its own Weston route?

B&NES had already funded a cycle route for precisely this journey. Its 2016/17 highways programme allocated £80,000 from the Local Growth Fund for “Weston Village to City Centre Cycle improvements”. A contemporary account describes the alignment along Weston Road, Crescent Lane and Upper Church Street. By November 2018, the council’s own infrastructure programme recorded: “Weston Cycle route completed.” Weston Road and Julian Road subsequently appeared within the boundaries of the Lower Lansdown liveable neighbourhood scheme. Here was a chance to connect two council investments. Capital programme · Contemporary account · Completion record, page 54 · Lower Lansdown road safety audit

What would it have cost to tackle the roundabout, improve protection on Weston Road and connect riders into the Circus and Lower Lansdown Liveable Neighbourhood? How would that compare with the park option on personal security after dark, the number of useful journeys, and the benefits for people walking and wheeling? A costed comparison might favour the park. Residents should be able to see which options B&NES compared and why the park came first, particularly while funding for Queen Square was still to be secured. £2.35 million funding decision · Council update on Queen Square

On 18 November, I asked B&NES for the preliminary and detailed route assessments, any assessment of continuing along Weston Road, the recorded comparison between the two alignments, and the advice behind the decision to leave SP04–SP06 unscored. The request asks one particularly important question: which records did Major actually have when he signed the replacement decision on 28 October? B&NES should publish those records. Where an assessment is missing, it should say so, carry it out and publish the result. Read the request and follow the council’s response

Why is Walk Ride Bath against this?

We support two-way cycling at the park’s north-west entrance. We objected because B&NES called this a family-friendly route without showing how a family would get through the junctions at either end, or what evidence justified its assurances about a girl riding through the park after dark. Those are questions a parent has to answer before their child sets off.

B&NES has committed £2.35 million to the park section. Under the funding programme, approved projects must be under contract by 31 March 2027. Will those contracts cover improvements at Queen Square and the Weston Road and Park Lane roundabout? If either junction is left out, when will the council tackle it, and with what money?

Then try Amy’s test again. Build the park lane. The cyclist from Tennyson Road still has to get from the end of their street to the start of it. The girl riding home to Weston still has to negotiate Queen Square and the roundabout. For the parent who rules out that journey at either junction, take the £2.35 million park scheme out of the story and the ending is the same. Their daughter still isn’t cycling home.

Leave a Reply